Road to Duke
Amsterdam, New York, read about Tim Kolodziej before it could pronounce him. In the early 1960s the Recorder's evening sports pages carried the Amsterdam High School box scores, and one young reader later remembered going straight to the numbers beside a name he could not sound out. "K-O-L-O-D-Z-I-E-J;" he wrote decades later, "how the hell did they expect a 7-year-old kid to sound that one out?" That reader, the local historian behind The Amsterdam, NY Blog, wrote a birthday tribute to Kolodziej on April 10, 2019, and it remains the fullest account of his high school career that we have found.
Timothy Michael Kolodziej (the full name is in the Chanticleer, Duke's yearbook) was one of three children of Ed and Sally Kolodziej, who owned and ran Kuk's Grill on James Street; his college directory address was 72 James St. He played for the Amsterdam High School Hilltoppers in the Wilbur Lynch Gymnasium, which the blog calls "that glorious old pit of a gymnasium at the top of Brandt Place." The writer recalled that "most of the time, the number in the column alongside Tim Kolodziej's name would be something in the twenties." In his senior season, 1963-64, it reached the forties twice: 40 points against New Rochelle and 42 against Johnstown.
The box scores, the blog says, could not show the rest of it. He was "six feet five inches tall, fast, and strong, could jump, had great basketball instincts and was also extremely smart." Art Hoefs, who wrote the Recorder's "Art of Sports" column, used the phrase "slashing and dashing" for the way he drove the lane, and the crowds came: "hundreds were cramming into that glorious old pit of a gymnasium." He left Amsterdam High with a school record 1,106 career points, a mark that stood until Mike Sollecito, class of 1978, passed it with 1,221, and with what the blog describes as "a four-year-scholarship to play for Duke University." He wore No. 32 in high school. At Duke he would wear 31.
At Duke
Freshmen could not play varsity basketball in 1964-65, so Kolodziej started for Chuck Daly's freshman team, the Baby Imps. The 1965 Chanticleer listed the opening lineup as "Ron Wendelin, Tim Kolodziej, Lewis, Joe Kennedy, and Warren Chapman," and pictured Daly instructing "the high-powered Tim Kolodziej, Mike Lewis and Joe Kennedy." The class went 10-0 in the first semester, including a 100-90 win over the North Carolina freshmen, and the yearbook judged the team "probably the best freshman team in the country" until "the unfortunate loss of two of its starters at midseason." The two were Kennedy and Kolodziej. "The loss of Kennedy and Kolodziej hurt the Devils when second semester play got under way," the Chanticleer wrote; the Imps went 3-3 the rest of the way and finished 13-3. The yearbook gives no reason for their absence, and we have not found one.
He did not appear in a varsity game in 1965-66 until Jan. 29, 1966, at NC State. That team went 26-4, won the ACC and reached the Final Four at Cole Field House. Kolodziej played in six games, scoring 15 points; his best night was 11 points on 3-of-4 shooting and 5-of-6 free throws in an 81-55 win over Virginia, and he scored 2 in the 79-77 win over Utah in the national third-place game.
With Jack Marin and Steve Vacendak gone, he moved into the rotation as a junior. In the Daily Tar Heel's 1966-67 preview Bubas named the candidates to replace Marin, Kolodziej among them, and said: "No one player is fundamentally as good all around as Jack (Marin). We've got some good boys who're fighting for spots." Kolodziej won one. He scored 14 in the opener at Virginia Tech, then went west with the seventh-ranked Blue Devils to face No. 1 UCLA and Lew Alcindor in Pauley Pavilion on back-to-back nights: he fouled out without scoring in the first game and had 14 points and 8 rebounds in the second. He scored a career-high 19 against Virginia on Dec. 16 and again at NC State on Feb. 8.
On Jan. 3, 1967, an hour before the Penn State game, Bubas suspended nine players for what he called training-rule violations. The Associated Press reported that "starters Mike Lewis, Bob Riedy, Dave Golden and Tim Kolodziej were 'temporarily suspended,'" along with five reserves. "It's a privilege, not a right to play college basketball," Bubas said, and: "A position of leadership is a lonely one, and I have been lonely for the last couple of days." Duke won 89-84 with Bob Verga and the reserves. The suspensions were brief; Kolodziej played 17 minutes against North Carolina four days later, and a Daily Tar Heel photo from that 59-56 Carolina win shows Bob Lewis driving "and is fouled by Tim Kolodziej."
He finished the season at 9.0 points and 5.3 rebounds a game, his best year. The 1967 Chanticleer noted his 13 rebounds as "Lewis, with 19 rebounds, and forward Tim Kolodziej with 13, led a Duke front line which consistently swept the boards" in a 91-75 win over West Virginia, and his 12 points in a 113-71 rout at Wake Forest. In the ACC Tournament he played 37 minutes and scored 16 with 9 rebounds in the 69-66 semifinal win over South Carolina, then had 11 in the loss to North Carolina in the final. Duke went 18-9 and lost to Southern Illinois in the NIT.
As a senior in 1967-68 he came off the bench for a team that went 22-6 and climbed into the top ten. The 1968 Chanticleer's season diary put his role plainly: "Coach Vic Bubas proves he has bench strength . . . Tim Kolodziej can fill in at forward." He made 76 of 96 free throws (79.2 percent), had 17 points at Abilene Christian and 16 with 8 rebounds against Clemson, played 21 minutes in the 87-86 triple-overtime win over North Carolina on March 2, 1968, and closed his career at Madison Square Garden with 12 points against Oklahoma City and 16 points and 9 rebounds in the NIT quarterfinal loss to Saint Peter's.
His teammates gave him the Glenn E. "Ted" Mann Jr. Award for 1968, which goes to the player voted by the team as contributing the most to team morale. Off the court the record is just as full. The 1968 Chanticleer lists him as a mathematics major in Phi Delta Theta, vice president of the Bench and Bar pre-law society, and a member of Old Trinity and Omicron Delta Kappa, the leadership honor society, and it names him among the seniors chosen for Who's Who. He lettered three times and finished with 417 points and 229 rebounds in 60 games.
After Duke
The Amsterdam blog picks up the thread: "After graduating from Duke, he married the former Sandy Gallagher, also from Amsterdam." A commenter on the post remembered babysitting Sandy, whose father owned Gallagher's Jewelers. The couple settled in New Hampshire, and somewhere along the way they began spelling the family name the way it sounds. "They now live in New Hampshire and are spelling their last name 'K-O-L-O-J-A-Y,'" the blog says. "Even a seven-year-old box score reader could have figured out how to pronounce that."
Under that name the math major built a career in insurance. His LinkedIn profile lists his Duke degree as a BA in mathematics, with "Phi Delta Theta; Varsity Basketball" under activities, and an MBA from Southern New Hampshire University, 1978 to 1980. His later résumé there begins in 1992 at Milliman, the actuarial consulting firm, where he worked in Massachusetts until 2001 and "was involved in the formation of three insurance companies, MEMIC, Kentucky Employers Mutual, and Missouri Employers Mutual," all of them workers' compensation insurers. From 2001 to 2005 he was president of Insurance Industry Consultants, LLC, in Atlanta, "an Actuarial and Insurance Consulting Practice that specialized in small insurance companies and self insurance groups." In October 2005 Business Insurance reported that "Tim Kolojay has been named senior vp in Willis' captive and actuarial practice in Burlington, Vt." Captive insurance, the specialty he kept returning to, is the business of companies and groups forming insurers of their own. South Carolina's captive regulator lists Timothy Kolojay among its approved actuaries.
From 2007 to 2009 he was a director at CMS Financial Services in Albany, N.Y., with "sole responsibility to find and procure a Life Insurance Company to put into the long term care insurance business"; the company bought United Security Insurance Company of America, and he served on its board. A 2008 Brattleboro Reformer item placed a Timothy Kolojay, 61, of Hopkinton, N.H., in a minor crash on Route 9 in Marlboro, Vt., an age that matches a Duke class of 1968. In 2009 he joined Energi in Peabody, Mass., an insurer for the energy industry, as chief underwriting officer. "We underwrite risks in the energy industry and provide an exclusive state of the art safety and loss control program for our insureds," his profile says of those years. He was senior vice president of underwriting operations at Energi Insurance Services from 2009 to 2017 and president of Energi RE, "a captive insurance company domiciled in North Carolina," from 2014 to 2017. His profile counts those years as part of 15 at the eMaxx Assurance Group of Companies, from 2009 to 2024.
In August 2017 he became president of eCaptiv, an eMaxx company built around captive insurance programs. In a Risk & Insurance roundtable in September 2023 he described leading a state-by-state review of the company's book and a reworked pricing plan: "We designed the program based on rate adequacy," he said, and "we brought our businesses from $250 million down to about $180 million based on results of our study." eMaxx's chief executive, Brian McCarthy, credited him: "So Tim actually headed up the team internally." Kolojay also talked about bringing in young people as summer interns and moving them through marketing, underwriting and distribution, and he had a view of the industry earned over decades. "I've been in it a long time. I've seen a lot of things," he said. "I've worked for AIG, and so I look at what you can do with a small organization like we have compared to an AIG."
Where Is He Now
Picture the trophy case at Amsterdam High School. The blog's author, writing in 2019, wondered whether Kolodziej's No. 32 jersey and the game ball from his 42-point night against Johnstown were still on display there. "If not," he wrote, "they should be." We do not know the answer.
What we do know is that the slashing forward from James Street became Tim Kolojay of New Hampshire, a three-year letterman who spent more than three decades in insurance. His LinkedIn profile shows him retiring from the eMaxx Assurance Group in January 2024 after 15 years while still listing himself as president of eCaptiv, based in Peabody, Mass. We have not reached him, so we do not have his side of the story: why he and Joe Kennedy left the freshman team in 1965, what Bubas said in that locker room in January 1967, what he did in the years between Duke and Milliman, or what it meant to be voted the teammate who did the most for the team's morale.
The boy who could not pronounce Kolodziej in 1963 eventually learned. The family made it easier on everyone else.