Road to Duke
In March 1965 the Ashe Central Panthers rode an activity bus down the mountain to Winston-Salem for the state playoffs, and on the way they stopped at a house in Glendale Springs. Their coach, Wade Rose, was inside, dying of liver cancer. He gave them a last word of encouragement and they went on without him. One of the starters on that bus was a tall senior from West Jefferson named Bob Francis.
His full name, as the Duke yearbook would later print it, was Robert Dean Francis. He was one of a group of seventh graders Rose took over at Jefferson Elementary when Rose, 22 and fresh out of Lees-McRae, was hired to coach the seventh and eighth grade team. The Ashe County Historical Society's account of the team, written by Josh Beckworth, lists them: Charlie Bowers, Roger Howell, David Bower, David Mullis, Bob Francis, Larry Cockerham and Lanney Blevins. There were no youth leagues in the mountains then. "We didn't know nothing about nothing," Howell recalled.
Rose kept them for six years. When the Ashe Central varsity job opened (two coaches from outside the county had come and gone quickly, one of them a young Bucky Waters, who would later coach Duke), Rose applied, promised a state championship, and moved up with his boys at 23. He made them go to bed early before games, change their diets and wear a suit and tie on game day. He had them to his house for cookouts and took them to church. "Outside of family, [basketball] was his number one thing in life," Howell said.
Two years before that last season Rose had been told he had six months to live. He told almost no one. "He knew he was going to stay with those boys until they won," his widow, Gwen Ashley, told the historical society. In the spring of 1964 an assistant, Morris Walker, found him collapsed in the coach's office; a tumor on his liver had ruptured. That summer Howell was guarding him in a pickup game when Rose went up to shoot. "His shirt pulled up and he had this tube. I thought 'my lord.' I'd never seen nothing like that before."
The 1964-65 Panthers had 14 players, and the historical society names Francis among the starters with Bowers, Howell, David Bowers and Lanney Blevins; Mullis came back from Texas to make it a six-man core. They lost once, 48-43 at North Wilkes, and beat North Wilkes twice afterward, the second time for the District 7 title. By then Rose was too sick to coach and Walker ran the team. "He knew what Coach Rose's philosophy was. . . he didn't change a thing," Bowers said.
At the hotel in Winston-Salem the other schools had chartered buses and blazers. Ashe Central had blue jeans and letter jackets. "They were hollering for us to 'get back to the sticks,'" Howell said. "Coach Walker wouldn't let us say nothing. He said 'we'll take care of things tonight.' And we did." The Panthers beat Stedman 69-55 and Havelock 90-76, and in the 2-A final they beat Anson County 85-68 (the state association's record book has it 84-68). The historical society's photo from that game shows Francis going up for a shot. The North Carolina High School Athletic Association lists Ashe Central as the 1965 2-A champion, 25-1, coach Wade Rose. It was the first state title any Ashe County team had won.
Rose listened to the final on the radio from his bed. That night the players picked up the Winston-Salem Journal and read the headline, "Ashe Wins 2-AA Title for Dying Coach." "We didn't realize he was on his deathbed," Bowers said. Rose died less than 12 hours later, while the team was on its way home. On March 17, four days after the championship, the players gathered in the John Luke Memorial gym in Glendale Springs for his funeral.
At Duke
That fall Francis was at Duke. The 1966 Chanticleer lists Robert D. Francis of West Jefferson in the class of 1969 and puts "B. Francis" in the second row of the freshman team photo, with Dave Golden, C.B. Claiborne, Steve Vandenberg and Fred Lind behind him. Coach Tom Carmody's Blue Imps went 11-5 and averaged 89.2 points a game; the yearbook's summary names a "starting six" of Golden, Gene Bromstead, Claiborne, Vandenberg, Lind and Larry Dempsey, and does not mention Francis.
As a sophomore in 1966-67 he was on Vic Bubas's varsity. The 1967 Chanticleer lists Bob Francis on the basketball roster, and Duke's stats archive carries him as a sophomore with no number, position or height recorded. Duke was a top program then, two years removed from the Final Four, with Bob Verga, Mike Lewis and Bob Riedy, and there was little room for a sophomore from the mountains. In our records he played in one game. It happened to be the strangest game of the season.
On New Year's Eve, by the account of Mike Burke (who wrote about it years later in a piece on Steve Vandenberg), Bubas caught most of his team out after curfew. On January 3, 1967, before Penn State came to the Indoor Stadium, Bubas told reporters he had suspended nine players, four of them starters, for training violations. "It's a privilege, not a right to play college basketball," he said, according to the Associated Press. He would not say what rule had been broken or how long the suspensions would last. "A position of leadership is a lonely one, and I have been lonely for the last couple of days."
The AP named the nine: starters Mike Lewis, Bob Riedy, Dave Golden and Tim Kolodziej, and reserves Tony Barone, Warren Chapman, Ron Wendelin, Joe Kennedy and Jim Liccardo. That left Verga and the sophomores. Burke wrote that Bubas "had just six players in uniform." The 1967 Chanticleer told it this way: Duke "met Penn State in the Indoor Stadium with only a six-man squad to carry Duke victory hopes," and Verga, "who burned the nets for 38 points, and able reserves C. B. Claiborne, Bob Francis, Stuart McKaig, Fred Lind, and Steve Vandenberg, launched a spirited attack which downed the Lions 89-84."
The box score in Duke's stats archive shows how thin the bench was. Verga, Vandenberg, Claiborne and McKaig each played all 40 minutes. Lind played 22 and Francis 18, so the two of them shared the fifth spot. In his 18 minutes Francis made one of two shots and all three of his free throws, for five points, with four rebounds, an assist and one foul. Duke went over .500 for the first time that season, at 5-4.
The suspensions were short. Four days later the regulars were back for North Carolina, and Francis does not appear in another box score that season or in any later one. He did not letter, and the stats archive does not list him on the 1967-68 roster. His Duke career, as the record stands: one game, 18 minutes, five points, and a line in the yearbook as one of the reserves who saved a night that could have gone very badly for Vic Bubas.
After Duke
The 1968 Chanticleer still lists Robert Dean Francis, class of 1969, of West Jefferson, in its student directory and in the roster of his residence house. We did not find him in the 1969 yearbook.
The historical society's account of the 1965 team ends with what became of some of the players. David Mullis played four years at Appalachian State and was a captain. "Bob Francis went on to Duke," it says, "where he played basketball while earning a medical degree."
The federal registry of health care providers lists a Robert Dean Francis, M.D., an orthopaedic surgeon licensed in North Carolina, with a practice location in Hendersonville; that listing was last updated in 2007. Healthgrades lists a Dr. Robert Francis, orthopedic surgeon, at the VA Medical Center in Asheville, with Duke University medical school, 1977. The full name matches the one in the Duke yearbook, and the Ashe County account says he earned a Duke medical degree, so these appear to be the same man. We have not found a Duke record, a news story or a word from him that ties them together for certain, and we have not found the story of his years in medicine: where he trained after medical school, how long he practiced in the mountains, or when he retired.
Where Is He Now
In the historical society's photo from the 1965 state final, Bob Francis is in the air, shooting, in an Ashe Central uniform that his coach would never see him wear again. Two years later he was on the floor at Duke for the one night Vic Bubas needed every sophomore he had.
We don't yet know where he is today. If the record is right, the boy who learned the game from Wade Rose at Jefferson Elementary spent his working life as an orthopaedic surgeon in the same western North Carolina mountains, but we have not confirmed it, or anything since. If you are Bob Francis, or played with him in Ashe County or at Duke, or are part of his family, we would like to finish his story. The Panthers took care of things that night in Winston-Salem; we would like to know how the rest of it went.