Road to Duke
Late in a 1966 ACC Tournament semifinal, with North Carolina stalling and the score in the 20s, Dean Smith turned to his young assistant, Larry Brown, during a time-out and asked a question that had nothing to do with stars: which Duke player had the lowest free-throw percentage? Brown had the answer ready: Jim Liccardo. It was not a compliment, but it was a kind of fame, and it says something about the man. On a team of All-Americas, the 6-5 reserve from New Jersey was the one the other bench was talking about at the end of the night.
James Frank Liccardo came to Duke from West Orange, N.J., in the fall of 1962. The 1963 Chanticleer lists "James F. Liccardo" among the freshmen of the class of 1966, and its Kappa Sigma page puts "J. Liccardo" in that year's pledge class, seated a few names from a guard named B. Zimmer who would also play for Vic Bubas. The 1964 yearbook's student directory still has him in the class of '66, with a home address in West Orange. We have not found his birth date or the name of his high school; no source we could read gives either.
His class was a famous one. Jack Marin and Steve Vacendak were freshmen that year too, and North Carolina's 1963-64 basketball Blue Book, previewing Duke, listed "6-6 Jack Marin, 6-5 Jim Liccardo, 6-5 Phil Allen" among the "replacements" coming up from the freshman team. Marin and Vacendak joined the varsity that winter. Liccardo did not. His first varsity season in our records is 1964-65, when he was a sophomore, and by the 1966 yearbook he had become a member of the class of 1967. John Roth's Encyclopedia of Duke Basketball calls him "a rising sophomore" in the summer of 1964. None of the sources we found says why he lost the year.
At Duke
He arrived on the varsity in the fall of 1964, a forward wearing No. 32 on a team that had just played for the national championship. The 1965 Chanticleer's team photo puts "Jim Liccardo" in the standing row between assistant coach Bucky Waters and Bob Riedy, with freshman coach Chuck Daly at the end. As a sophomore he played in 11 games and scored 16 points. Against South Carolina on Dec. 12, 1964, he went 1 for 1 from the floor and 3 for 4 at the line and took five rebounds; against Virginia in February he had seven rebounds.
He was a pitcher, too. The Alumni Register's spring sports notes for 1965 reported that "Righthander Dean Helms posted top ERA (1.48) while Jim Liccardo pitched the most innings." The 1966 Chanticleer, looking back on Ace Parker's 8-17 baseball team, wrote: "Hurlers Jim Liccardo (3-6), Jay Hopkins (2-1), and Ken Helms (2-1) were standouts on the mound for the Duke nine."
The 1965-66 season was the one people remember. Duke went 26-4, won the ACC and reached the Final Four, and Liccardo was one of the first men off the bench. Previewing the Blue Devils that winter, The Daily Tar Heel wrote that "the Blue Devils' first reserves will come from 6-8 center Warren Chapman, 6-5 forward Jim Liccardo and 6-1 sophomore guard Ron Wendelin." He played in 24 games and scored 53 points. In the opener against Virginia Tech in Greensboro he made all four of his shots and all three of his free throws for 11 points, his career high; on New Year's Eve against Notre Dame he went 4 for 4 again. Against Penn State in January he had 10 rebounds in 17 minutes. When NC State took Duke to the wire at the end of January, the yearbook gave the bench the credit: "the rebounding of Marin and Lewis and the top notch play of subs Ron Wendelin, Jim Liccardo, and Warren Chapman made the difference."
Then came the stall. In the ACC semifinal in Raleigh on March 4, 1966, North Carolina held the ball against the favored Blue Devils, and Duke won 21-20. The Alumni Register's account has Liccardo in the middle of the ending. Vacendak tied the game with 2:19 left. "After Carolina missed a free throw opportunity and the rebound was grabbed by Jim Liccardo, the Blue Devils froze the ball until only sixteen seconds remained." Mike Lewis was fouled with four seconds left and made the winning free throw.
On the other bench, the same minutes produced the story North Carolina writers kept telling for decades. In John Feinstein's The Legends Club, Brown, then Smith's assistant, remembered the time-out: "Coach Smith wanted to foul Jim Liccardo," he said. "He wasn't a very good foul shooter, and it would have been one-and-one. His theory was, even if he made both, which he didn't think he would," Carolina would get the ball and the last shot. Art Chansky told it as a test. In Dean's Domain, Smith "was testing him to make sure he knew the Duke player with the lowest free-throw percentage. When Brown answered back (Jim) Liccardo, Smith smiled and decided to keep playing tight defense." In The Dean's List, Chansky has Smith telling Brown, "No, I am just getting you to think." Liccardo, for the record, made 7 of 11 free throws that season.
At the Final Four in College Park he played five minutes against Kentucky in the 83-79 semifinal loss and 14 in the third-place game against Utah, and the yearbook gave him the last word of the season. With Duke up a point and seven seconds left, a Utah reserve went to the line for a one-and-one. "Two straight time-outs by Coach Bubas unnerved him, he missed, and Liccardo grabbed the rebound." Duke won 79-77.
He switched uniforms almost at once. "Jim Liccardo discarded the elaborate underwear that goes by the name of a basketball uniform and donned baseball knickers one day later to take the mound against Kent State in the opening game of the season," the Alumni Register reported. "He pitched a 7-6 victory." The Register added that "a basketball season composed of several come-from-behind victories must have prepared Liccardo for the Kent State game," which Duke won in the ninth on Dick Warren's two-run double, with Liccardo "the last man to cross the plate." That spring he received the Ted Mann Jr. Award, which Roth describes as the award "for the reserve contributing most to team morale." It was named for a Duke forward who had died in the summer of 1964. Roth notes that Liccardo was a rising sophomore when Mann died.
His senior year began with the strangest week of the Bubas years. After the Blue Devils beat Wake Forest in Greensboro on Dec. 30, 1966 (Liccardo played 30 minutes and scored eight), Bubas suspended nine players before the Penn State game on Jan. 3 for what The Daily Tar Heel called "training rule violations," and Liccardo was one of them. The Associated Press named "reserves Tony Barone, Warren Chapman, Ron Wendelin, Jim Liccardo and Joe Kennedy" along with four starters. "The coach would say only, 'it is a privilege, not a right to play'" college basketball. Verga and five reserves beat Penn State 89-84 without them.
Four days later, against North Carolina in the Indoor Stadium, Liccardo played 33 minutes, the most of his career. Duke lost 59-56, but The Daily Tar Heel's game story shows him in the comeback. "Jim Liccardo and Vandenberg made good on foul shots," and later, when C.B. Claiborne missed the second of two free throws, it "was rebounded by Jim Liccardo, who twisted the ball through the basket." In February, Roth writes, Bubas "started seniors Verga, Bob Riedy, Jim Liccardo, and Stuart McKaig" for the home finale against Wake Forest; Liccardo played 23 minutes and scored seven in a 97-84 win. He played 22 minutes and took eight rebounds in the ACC final loss to North Carolina, and his college career ended in the NIT against Southern Illinois on March 13, 1967.
In three varsity seasons he played in 58 games and scored 121 points, 2.1 a game, with 2.0 rebounds a game. The media guide lists him as a letterman in 1966 and 1967. Roth's verdict is short: "Considered a steady and valuable reserve, James Frank Liccardo played in 58 games in three years on the varsity." He graduated with the class of 1967; the Duke alumni directories list his degree as an A.B.
After Duke
Liccardo went into banking in northern New Jersey, and the clearest record of his career is in Duke's own alumni directories. The 1985 Duke University Alumni Directory lists "Liccardo, James; '67" as a senior vice president of the Summit Trust Co. of Summit, N.J., the bank of the Summit Bancorporation.
By the end of the decade he was running the company's mortgage business. The Summit Bancorporation's 1989 annual report lists The Summit Mortgage Company, Inc., "Serving the State of New Jersey," with "James Liccardo, President" at the top of its management, and puts him in the front row of the photo of the holding company's subsidiary heads. The 1997 Directory of Corporate Affiliations still lists him as president of The Summit Mortgage Company (its text has his middle initial as "E.", which looks like a misprint for F.).
The later directories add his graduate degree. The 2005 Duke University Alumni Directory lists "Liccardo, James F.; T '67 AB; MBA Seton Hall Univ.; Sr. VP, Summit Mortgage Co.," and the 2010 Duke University Alumni Today gives the same degrees and the title "Senior Vice President, Summit Mortgage Company." We have not found when he earned the M.B.A., when he left Summit, or what he did after that.
Where Is He Now
Picture the 1966 Duke bench: a 6-5 forward in No. 32 who was pitching for the baseball team within days of the Final Four, and whom Dean Smith's staff, for one time-out, wanted at the free-throw line more than anyone else in blue. That is where the record is strongest. Where Jim Liccardo is today, we don't know.
The last trace we have is the 2010 alumni directory, which still listed him as a senior vice president of Summit Mortgage Company with an M.B.A. from Seton Hall. We have found no obituary, no retirement notice and nothing after that. He belongs to the generation of Bubas players who saw Duke become a national program, and his teammates from those years are still telling their stories.
So this page stays In Progress. It is the story of the reserve the other bench was talking about, and we would like to know how the rest of it went.