Road to Duke
In Syracuse in the autumn of 1938, a Syracuse University end named Phil Allen caught the winning touchdown pass from Wilmeth Sidat-Singh as the Orange came back from 10-0 down in the fourth quarter to beat Cornell, 19-17. The Greater Syracuse Sports Hall of Fame still calls it "The Catch." Twenty-four years later a boy who carried the same name, Philip Henry Allen Jr., left that city for Durham and a place on Vic Bubas's basketball team.
We should say plainly how we connect the two, because no source we have read puts both men in one sentence. Duke's yearbooks list the basketball player as Philip Henry Allen Jr. of Syracuse, N.Y., with a family address on Parsons Drive. Syracuse's football hall of fame player was Phil Allen, who lettered in 1937, 1938 and 1939, served in the Navy from 1942 to 1945 and was elected supervisor of the Town of Geddes, on Syracuse's west side, in 1961. He married Virginia "Ginnie" Guilfoil, the golfer the New York State Golf Association calls "arguably the most dominant female golfer in Syracuse's history." When she died in 2008, the association's Hall of Fame page says, she was "survived by son Phil Allen, Jr. and wife Sherri; daughter Ginnie and husband Rick Russo." A Syracuse boy named Philip Allen Jr., of the right age, with a father named Phil Allen: we think the match is very likely, and we would welcome the family's word on it.
If it holds, Phil Allen grew up in a sporting house. His parents married in 1942, and the golf association writes that "after spending some years in Alexandria, VA due to her husband Phil Allen being in the U.S. Navy, the couple returned to New York and resettled in Syracuse." His father's hall of fame page says he "saw action during the D-Day Normandy invasion," then sat on the board of the Syracuse Chiefs and was a director of Syracuse University's Varsity Club and booster groups. His mother won nineteen Syracuse district titles. "Starting in 1955, when the family joined the Bellevue Country Club, she would reign as the women's club champion for 23 consecutive years!" In 1941 she had been the first Syracusan to win the New York State Women's Amateur.
We have not found his birth date, his high school or how Duke found him. He arrived in the fall of 1962 as a freshman from Syracuse, and that year's Chanticleer shows him in the Phi Kappa Sigma pledge class.
At Duke
Freshmen could not play varsity basketball in 1962-63, so Allen's first year was the freshman schedule while Art Heyman's senior team went to the Final Four. When he moved up as a sophomore, the 1964 Chanticleer recorded what Bubas told everyone before the season. He called December "the most challenging month" in Duke basketball history, and when pressed for an honest appraisal he said, "We'll have a good club. We'll have good speed and good depth."
Allen, a 6-4 forward, was part of that depth. He wore No. 35 and played his first varsity game on November 30, 1963, in the opener against Penn State at Duke Indoor Stadium. Duke won 92-62, and our box score gives him two baskets and 10 rebounds. He played in five games that season and made six of his seven shots, among them a basket in the 104-69 win at North Carolina's Carmichael Auditorium on February 29, 1964. That team went 26-5, won the ACC and lost the national championship game to UCLA. In the varsity photograph he stands in the back row between Ted Mann Jr. and Frank Harscher.
As a junior in 1964-65 he played in twelve games, more than in either of his other seasons, starting with three minutes and a basket in the opener against Virginia Tech in Greensboro. The 1965 Chanticleer gave the bench its due: "These, and the bench depth, led by big Brent Kitching and Bob Reidy, provided varying blends of power in speed, defense, rebounding and high-scoring for the 1965 Dukes." The best night of his career came on February 6, 1965, against West Virginia: six minutes, two field goals in four tries and four free throws in four, eight points in a 109-89 win. Five days later he was one of the fourteen Blue Devils in a 136-72 rout of Virginia that set ACC records for points and field goals. The 1965 Chanticleer wrote that "the reserves accounted for the last 36 points" and that "all 14 Devils were hot from the floor (59%) and especially the foul line (26 of 31.)" Allen made both of his free throws that night. He went eight for eight from the line that season, and the yearbook's team photograph seats him at the end of the front row, beside Bob Verga. He also played a minute in the ACC Tournament final, a 91-85 loss to N.C. State.
His senior team was one of the best Duke had fielded. The 1966 Chanticleer began its basketball story: "Three words describe the 1965-66 Blue Devils: talent, poise, and heart." That team reached No. 1 in December, won the ACC and finished third at the Final Four. Allen played in nine games by our box scores, with a high of nine minutes and four points in a 102-67 win over Furman on December 14, 1965, when Duke was ranked first in the country. His last box score line came on February 12, 1966, three points in an 81-55 win over Virginia. By our box scores he did not get into a postseason game in either Final Four season.
Across three varsity seasons Allen played in 26 games in our box scores, and Duke won 25 of them; the only loss was that 1965 ACC final. He scored 45 points, made 17 of 37 field goals and 11 of 13 free throws, and earned three letters (1964, 1965, 1966). His senior entry in the 1966 Chanticleer reads, in full: "History; Phi Kappa Sigma; Basketball 1, 2, 3, 4." He graduated in 1966.
After Duke
Here the trail goes thin. We have not found Phil Allen in the Duke Alumni Register's class notes for 1966 through 1975, and we have not found a newspaper story, obituary or company page that ties a later career to the Duke forward. His father's hall of fame entry lists honors that run into the 1990s: Syracuse University's Letterman of Distinction award in 1975, the Corning Sports Hall of Fame in 1978 and the presidency of the Blind Men and Criers in 1992. The elder Phil Allen died in 1995.
What the record does say is that a Phil Allen Jr. was living, and married to a woman named Sherri, when his mother died in August 2008 at 91. The golf association counted six grandchildren and fifteen great-grandchildren in that family. Where he lived, what he did for a living and whether he stayed in Syracuse, the sources we could reach do not say, and we won't guess.
Where Is He Now
The clearest picture we have of Phil Allen is a row of photographs: a back-row forward in 1964, a front-row seat in 1965, a second-row place beside Steve Vacendak and Jack Marin in 1966, three seasons in the jersey of a program that kept going to the Final Four. Behind those pictures, if we have the family right, stand a father who made "The Catch" for Syracuse and a mother who won the Bellevue club title 23 years running.
We don't yet know where Phil Allen is today. If you are family, played with him at Duke or know him from Syracuse, we would like to finish the story of the Syracuse forward who wore No. 35 and was on the floor for 25 Duke wins.