Road to Duke
The first thing the Chronicle ever printed about Bob Fleischer was that he could rebound, and the second was that he could play golf well enough to have tied Jack Nicklaus for a course record. Both turned out to be the kind of thing you say about a player who is going to be around a while. He came to Duke in the fall of 1971 from Liberty High School, in the township north of Youngstown, Ohio, where he had averaged 26.9 points a game as a senior, made the All-State Class AA first team, and led the Leopards to league and county championships. He was 6-foot-8, which the paper would spend four years calling short for a center, and he chose Duke, he said that first winter, because "I liked the basketball program and I wanted to go to an academically good school."
Freshmen could not play varsity in 1971-72, so he spent the year on Neill McGeachy's freshman team with Kevin Billerman, Pete Kramer and Bill Suk, the four who would walk off the Cameron floor together in March 1975, and he spent it under the basket. He had 22 rebounds against Virginia's freshmen in December, 21 against Laurinburg, 21 against Ferrum, 20 against Carolina's "Tar Babies" in a game in which he "totally dominated the highly touted Ed Stahl," and six games of 20 or more in all. The ACC's final freshman statistics that spring listed him first in the conference in rebounding at 16.6 a game, ahead of everyone on an N.C. State freshman team that had David Thompson. Asked about it in February, he said the thing that would be true of him for four years: "I'm not very happy with my play this year. I feel as if something is missing. I don't feel as if I've had a bad year, but I don't think that I have performed anywhere near my potential." He was also, at 18, against letting freshmen play varsity ball, which the NCAA had just approved. "It would be impossible for a freshman to travel and keep his grades up," he said. "It's unfair to ask a freshman to miss that many classes and to take the pressure of varsity competition in his first year." He had not yet picked a major, and he meant it.
At Duke
He played three varsity seasons for three head coaches, and in all three he led Duke in rebounding. As a sophomore under Bucky Waters he averaged 11.0 points and 8.5 rebounds on a 12-14 team and was named the team's leading rebounder at the banquet. That summer he played for the United States at the Maccabiah Games in Israel, on a silver-medal team coached by Harry Litwack whose starting five included an 18-year-old high school senior named Ernie Grunfeld. When he got back, Waters quit, and it was Fleischer, "a top performer from last year's team," whom the Chronicle called for the players' side of it. "I feel that he was honest with us," he said. "He said that the team had been the recipient of bad publicity and that it might be better off if some of the spite aimed at him was eliminated." And: "I believe that his wife and family got a bad deal because of the bad publicity he received."
The junior year, McGeachy's one season, was the best basketball of his life, on a 10-16 team: 15.7 points and 12.4 rebounds a game, a rebounding average that only four Duke players have ever topped in a season, and none since. He had 31 at Wake Forest, 22 of them in the second half; 23 and 18 at Maryland against Len Elmore and Tom McMillen; 23 and 16 at Princeton on 8 of 11 shooting; 17 and 18 at Carmichael on March 2, 1974, in the game that Duke lost to Carolina after leading by eight with 17 seconds to play; and he outscored and outrebounded Clemson's 7-foot-1 freshman, Tree Rollins, 14 and 11 to 14 and 8. "Fleischer Consistent" became a recurring Chronicle subhead. The famous pass on January 19, 1974, the one Bobby Jones stole at the end of the first Carolina game, was "a cross-court lob pass intended for center Bob Fleischer." That March, with the athletic department deciding what to do about the program, Fleischer said something out loud that players did not say: "I have personally spoken with Carl James in the past, and I can tell you the atmosphere that's here now is not healthy for basketball. The people in the stands and the athletic department may think basketball is all wins and losses, but that is not the case." He was voted the team's most valuable player anyway, and the New York Nets of the ABA drafted him that spring, with a year of eligibility left. He stayed.
Bill Foster arrived in 1974, moved him to forward, told him to shoot, and got a senior season out of him that is still on the record books: 17.2 points, 10.5 rebounds, 62 percent from the floor, 77 percent from the line, co-captain with Billerman, second-team All-ACC, team MVP for the second year, and Academic All-America. "I've been trying to get Fly to take those outside shots more often all year long," Foster said after he went 4 for 5 against Georgia Tech. "He has a good touch from outside." Duke went 13-13, and for one stretch it was better than that: 6-2 before George Moses flunked out, a 99-96 overtime win over eighth-ranked North Carolina in the Big Four, and in late January the week when "when we control the boards we can run, and when we run we can win," as Fleischer put it after a 17-and-18 night at Davidson. He scored his 1,000th career point on February 5, 1975, in a win over Wake Forest, and the Chronicle admitted it "was almost overlooked in the excitement." Five days later, against Duquesne, he had 21 points and 18 rebounds.
The last week was the one he talked about. The night before the seniors' final home game, John Feinstein sat the four of them down for a piece he titled "1,000 wins, 3 coaches, little joy." "I'll be sorry it's all over," Fleischer said. "I know I'll think about it before and after the game, but once that ball is thrown up I'll have to put it all out of my mind." He and Billerman said they had noticed the empty seats and would have preferred packed houses. He said Duke's 1,000th win, the year before, had mattered to the players for one reason: "We wanted to get that for Coach McGeachy. Now no matter what, when people ask who was coach for Duke's 1,000th win the answer will be Neill McGeachy." And when Feinstein got to what the four years had cost, Fleischer was the one who answered straight: "The hardest thing about my four years has been living with the losing. Coming home and feeling terrible 16 times last year really hurt." The next afternoon he outplayed Mitch Kupchak, 24 points, 10 rebounds and blocked shots, in a 74-70 loss to 14th-ranked Carolina. "We have to go out there and play like it might be our last game," he said before the ACC Tournament. "But then, you really should play every game that way." It was his last game. He fouled out with 7:16 left against Clemson, on what the paper called "a very questionable charging call," and Clemson, "going to Croft after Fleischer fouled out," won 78-76 on Tree Rollins's tip-in. He left with 1,139 points and 817 rebounds in 78 games, the best field-goal percentage in Duke history at the time, and a losing record every season he played.
After Duke
The Buffalo Braves took him in the fourth round of the NBA draft on May 29, 1975, 70th overall, and that is as far as the NBA record goes; Basketball-Reference lists no games. He played professionally in Europe for a time, a fact that survives only as a line in Jim Sumner's recollection of him, and then he did the thing he had said, at 18, that he wanted Duke for. He came back to Durham and enrolled in the Duke University School of Medicine.
In November 1980 the Chronicle printed a letter from "Bob Fleischer, MS II, Duke basketball 1971-1975," a second-year medical student, about Tara McCarthy, the women's basketball scoring leader whose scholarship the athletic department had pulled after she quit the team with a hip injury. "As MVP of the Duke basketball team in 1974 and 1975, I guess I should have left Duke with positive feelings," he wrote, "yet I remember vividly that I felt then as Tara McCarthy feels now, i.e. 'I really don't have good feelings about the Duke Athletic Department now and I think that is something that will stay with me.' Well, I'm sorry to say that it did stay with me. If the facts in the case are exactly as presented in the Chronicle article, then all I can say is that it's a cheap, lousy thing to do, it's unbelievably short sighted and also that this sort of thing just doesn't happen in Chapel Hill." Five years after his last game he was still the player who said the thing out loud.
He took his M.D. at Duke, did a surgical internship at Dartmouth-Hitchcock in New Hampshire, and came back to Duke for his urology residency, which he finished in June 1989. He and his wife, Jo-Ann, had twin sons in August 1986, and one of them, Mark, suffered respiratory and cardiac arrest in the Duke emergency room at 19 days old; in 1989 the Fleischers filed a $6.5 million negligence suit against the university and its physicians' practice, a front-page story in the Chronicle that September. "Dr. Fleischer would have liked to avoid suing his alma mater if his child had developed correctly," their lawyer said. We have not found how the case ended. By then the family had moved to New Hartford, New York, outside Utica, and that is where he has practiced ever since: a board-certified urologist and a Fellow of the American College of Surgeons, with more than thirty years in the Mohawk Valley at the New Hartford and Syracuse offices, at Bassett Healthcare in Cooperstown and Herkimer, and, from 2021, at Upstate Urology at the Mohawk Valley Health System in Utica. His brother Jim, who played at Dartmouth and coached Duke's junior varsity while he was in law school there in 1974-75, is the other Fleischer in the Chronicle's files.
He came back for the alumni games, in 1981 and 1986 and 1987, and the 1988 program summed him up in the present tense: "Currently a doctor with a Duke MD. Drafted by Buffalo in 1975 and an Academic All-America in 1975, Fleischer was twice named team MVP and owns the top field goal percentage in Blue Devil history."
Where Is He Now
Dr. Robert P. Fleischer still sees patients in Utica, New York, at 73, which is not what most people do at 73 and is exactly what you would expect from a man who, as a college sophomore, objected to freshmen playing varsity because they would miss class. When Jim Sumner asked him, years later, about the losing seasons, he said he remembered none of the wins and all of the losses, and then he said the sentence that explains the rest of his life: "You don't learn anything from the wins, you learn a lot from the losses."
He learned a lot. He played three losing seasons for three coaches, at 6-foot-8 against Burleson and Elmore and Rollins, and led the team in rebounding every one of them; he said what he thought about the athletic department when he was a junior and again when he was a medical student; he came home feeling terrible 16 times in a season and went to medical school anyway, at his alma mater, and then sued it. The Chronicle's word for him, from January 1974 on, was "consistent." The word Duke Basketball Report used fifty years later was "steady." He has been the same person the whole time, and the record, for once, agrees with the player.
If you played with Bob Fleischer at Liberty or at Duke, or have been his patient in the Mohawk Valley, we would like to hear from you.