Road to Duke
The Chronicle's first description of Bill Suk, in December 1971, reads like a scouting report on a player who was going to be a star: "a four-time All-Stater from Illinois" who "broke his school scoring records in basketball, while also lettering in football and track. Although only six-five, Suk has twice garnered 27 rebounds in a single game." He came from the south suburbs of Chicago, Midlothian on Duke's rosters, and he had been the kind of high school athlete who does everything: four years of basketball, three of football, two of baseball, one of track. "I played football in my first three years in high school," he said that winter, "but when I got to be a senior, I decided to devote all my time to playing basketball." Northwestern wanted him. He wanted the South and the school. "I came down to the school and it really impressed me. I liked Coach Waters and the basketball program at Duke."
He was a freshman in the last Duke class that played a freshman season, with Kevin Billerman, Bob Fleischer, Pete Kramer and Neil Chinault, and on that team he was something the varsity would never quite find a use for: the best all-around player on the floor. He scored 15 against Virginia's freshmen and 14 the following week, hit the jumper that started the run that buried Ferrum, and made both ends of a one-and-one to bring Duke within two of Carolina's freshmen in December. The season review in March 1972 gave him the highest compliment on the page. "It would not be out of order to assert that Bill Suk, a 6-5 guard, was the most complete player on the squad, although he was not the most impressive statistically. Suk repeatedly was assigned to the opposition's most dangerous offensive threat, besides supplying Billerman with valuable backcourt" help. In February, asked about his goals, he had said he wanted "to play an even larger role on the team in rebounding, defense and scoring." He was undecided between psychology and religion as a major. He was, like every one of his classmates, against the new rule letting freshmen play varsity: "I think the only ones it will really be good for is the superstars."
At Duke
He was never a superstar, and the Chronicle's varsity preview in December 1972 explains why Duke kept thinking he might be: "Suk was a complete player as a freshman, being the team's top defensive player, besides adding punch on offense." The punch never came. In three varsity seasons, for Bucky Waters, Neill McGeachy and Bill Foster, he played 70 games and scored 193 points, 2.8 a game, and shot 41 percent. What he did instead was guard people. In March 1973, when Virginia's Barry Parkhill was scoring "virtually at will" on Gary Melchionni, "the league's best defensive guard," McGeachy's staff sent in Suk. In February 1974 he and Kramer took turns on David Thompson. In January 1975, with Tate Armstrong sick and Billerman and Kramer nursing ankles, Foster started him at Wake Forest for one reason: "Suk will start on Skip Brown because I want a big man on him. He really hurt us in Greensboro with those 15-20 foot jump shots." The Chronicle's preview of the N.C. State game that month put it plainly: "Suk plays what may be the best defense on the team and has faced Thompson in the past."
Jim Sumner, looking back at the 1970s for Duke Basketball Report, called him the most curious case on the roster: "His coaches and teammates agreed that Suk could dominate in practices, looking for all the world like an All-ACC player. But he could never carry that over to games." That is the whole scouting report, and it is also, read closely, a story about a player who decided somewhere along the way that games were not the point.
He had his night. On February 5, 1975, against Wake Forest in Cameron, Duke protected a lead for the last ten minutes with a patient offense and the Deacons fouled, and Suk, a 71-percent foul shooter for his career, made six in a row. "I don't think about anything special at the line," he said afterward. "I just try not to carry the ball and shoot it right up." Duke won 75-68. Three weeks later, the night before his last home game, John Feinstein sat down with the four seniors, and Suk was the one who did not fit the piece. The others wanted to play professionally; Suk did not. The others were bothered by the empty seats; Suk was not. "I guess I would probably do the same thing most students do, just go to the big games," he said. "Most of the time people have studying they have to do on weeknights." To Suk, Feinstein wrote, basketball was "just a game," where the other three called it "the most important thing" in their lives. "It's just been a really exciting experience meeting all the people and making the friends I have," Suk said. "Basketball used to be the most important thing in my life, but that has gradually changed. Now it's important but for much different reasons. My friendship with the guys is probably the most important thing about it now." And: "I'm ready to end my basketball career. I want to concentrate on other things."
He had an answer, too, for the question he had been asked for three years, which was whether it had been disappointing to be a star in high school and a sub in college. "It's like asking the kid who got straight A's in high school and got C's and D's in college if it was disappointing," he said. "If he learned from it and enjoyed it, how can it be disappointing?" He scored two points in his last game, the ACC Tournament loss to Clemson, and was done.
After Duke
Feinstein's piece recorded his plans, and they are the last record we have. "Bill Suk's basketball career will end next week in Greensboro at the ACC tournament. Next year he hopes to work with the underprivileged either in Boston, Philadelphia or possibly Durham. After that he would like to enter the seminary. Basketball will become part of his past."
That is where the public trail stops. He did not play in Europe, did not appear in the Chronicle's lists of alumni-game participants through the 1980s, and did not, as far as any searchable record shows, coach. We searched his name with Midlothian and Chicago, with Duke, with seminary and ministry and the churches of the south suburbs, and with the Illinois high school associations that would have named a four-time all-state player, and found nothing we could stand behind. "Suk" is an uncommon name, which makes the silence more telling, not less: a man who said at 22 that basketball would become part of his past appears to have meant it.
Where Is He Now
We do not know where Bill Suk is, or whether he became the minister he said he wanted to be. He would be about 73. What we have is a player who was the most complete freshman on a team that produced a coach, a doctor and a lawyer, who spent three varsity years as the man sent in to guard Parkhill and Thompson and Skip Brown, who made six free throws in a row on the one night the building asked him to, and who, when a reporter came to write the elegy for his class, declined to be sad. "If he learned from it and enjoyed it, how can it be disappointing?"
Of the twelve Duke seniors of 1974, 1975 and 1976 who all took their degrees, he is the one who told the Chronicle, in so many words, that the degree and the friends were what he came for, and that the games were the price. It is not the usual thing for a four-time all-state player to say. It may be the most honest thing on these pages.
If you played with Bill Suk in Illinois or at Duke, or know where he went after 1975, we would like to hear from you. This page has his best quote and none of his life after it.