5 of 6 stars.Meets the quality bar
Profile quality: 5 of 6
  • Story finished (not In Progress)
  • All four sections written
  • 7,000+ characters8,204 characters
  • Direct quotes31 quotes
  • 3+ sources32 sources
  • Roster facts filled in
  • Birth date
  • House style (no em dashes)
  • Games backed by box scores3 seasons backed
  • Reviewed within a yearlast updated 2026-11-17
  • Original interviewnot yet
How the stars work →

Gary Melchionni

The third of South Jersey's basketball Melchionni brothers, who scored 39 on Gary Melchionni Day to beat No. 3 Maryland, made first-team All-ACC, played two seasons for Phoenix, and came back to lead Duke's alumni.

Guard6'3"1970–732nd Rd, 33rd — Phoenix Suns (1973)
77 GP • 803 pts • 10.4 ppg • 1972-73: 15.8 ppg, first-team All-ACC, team MVP, best defensive player • 39 pts vs. No. 3 Maryland, Feb. 3, 1973 • Second-team All-ACC 1972 • Two-time captain • Phoenix Suns 1973-75 (137 GP, 7.8 ppg) • Duke Law J.D. 1981 • Duke Alumni Association president 2001-02
Now: Retired Lancaster, Pa., lawyer (Stevens & Lee, employment and labor); Duke Law J.D. 1981; president of the Duke Alumni Association 2001-02 and a Duke trustee from 2001. Father of Duke guard Lee Melchionni.

Road to Duke

February 3, 1973, was, as Neill McGeachy would put it a year later, Gary Melchionni Day. Maryland, the third-ranked team in the country, came in with Len Elmore, Tom McMillen and a freshman named John Lucas. Duke was 8-9. Melchionni had spent three years as the guard who ran the offense and guarded the other team's best player. That afternoon he made 68 percent of his shots and scored 39 points, a career high, and Duke won 85-81. "Gary Melchionni scored and scored and scored again," the Chronicle wrote, while the student section chanted "Amen!" A year later McGeachy, losing at College Park, summed up the difference between the two seasons in one line: "A year ago today it was Gary Melchionni Day and now it's John Lucas Day."

He was born January 19, 1951, in Camden, New Jersey, and grew up in one of South Jersey's best-known basketball families. His father paved much of the backyard so his four sons could play, and all four earned college scholarships. The oldest, Bill, was an All-American at Villanova, the MVP of the 1966 NIT, and by the time Gary got to Duke a star for the New York Nets. "In a way there was some pressure," Gary said, "but it's always been something I've accepted. It has shown me the opportunities that were open by playing ball and has given me an incentive to stick with basketball."

At Bishop Eustace Prep in Pennsauken he was the reason for a 26-0 season and a state championship, averaging 16 points and six assists; he was named New Jersey player of the year and made both the public and Catholic all-state teams. Vic Bubas recruited him first and Bucky Waters, Bubas's successor, finished the job. "I went down for my official visit in the spring of 1969, and I was pretty much sold on the place after that," he said years later. "You just get blown away by the beauty of the campus."

At Duke

He came in with Alan Shaw, Richie O'Connor, Jeff Dawson and Jim Fitzsimmons, the "highly touted frosh five," and the 1969-70 freshmen went 16-0. Melchionni averaged 17.1 points, led the team in assists, made 68 of 77 free throws by late February, and scored more than he had in high school. "My scoring average this year is a little higher than last season because in high school I tried to balance my play and work for assists," he said. Scrimmaging against the varsity helped. "We were in awe of the varsity at first but once we got our plays working we could almost hold our own."

As a sophomore he won the point guard job from senior Dick DeVenzio, and then lost most of the season to mononucleosis and an ankle injury, averaging 4.6 points for a 20-10 team that finished fourth in the NIT. In 1971-72 he was a tri-captain, and in the second game he severely sprained an ankle against Virginia and left on crutches. When he came back he led the ACC in free throw shooting for a time, averaged 11.8 points, made the second-team All-ACC with Shaw, and was voted the team's best defensive player. When Richie O'Connor quit in February and a Raleigh television station reported that the players had voted to keep him out, Melchionni was one of those who called the report false. "This vote was in no way a final 'no' to Richie's rejoining the team," he said. "The players have not shut him off from coming back." After the 76-74 upset of Carolina on the night the building became Cameron, he explained that "we were basically in a 2-3 zone, with just some man-to-man coverage," and a month later, with Duke on a winning streak, he talked about the people in the stands. "The fans at the Indoor Stadium are the most loyal group of fans I've ever come across," he said. "I've played up and down the East Coast and I've watched my brothers play all over and the fans here are without equal."

His senior season began with tendinitis in an ankle, and the team struggled. Then came Maryland. "I started to mature as a total offensive player at the end of last year," he said afterward. "My shot has changed. I shoot the ball over my head, giving me better sight line to the basket." He described basketball the way an English major might, and he was one, studying under Reynolds Price. "You always want perpetual motion on the court, but you want it to be controlled motion," he said. "If a player stops moving he might as well be a chair on the court. You create openings by making the defense move." The 39 points made him the ACC Player of the Week, and he followed with 22 against Wake Forest. By March the Chronicle was calling him "the league's best defensive guard," and he was named first-team All-ACC. Looking ahead to the tournament, he said: "Being my last college games, I'd sure like to make them enjoyable." Duke lost to Virginia in the first round, and Waters thanked Melchionni and Shaw for three years of "outstanding service." At the banquet his teammates gave him three of the five awards: most valuable player, best defensive player, and the assists leader. He averaged 15.8 points that season and finished with 803 career points. He was also a GTE/CoSIDA Academic All-American.

After Duke

The Phoenix Suns drafted him in the second round, 33rd overall, in April 1973, and the ABA's San Antonio Spurs took him in the sixth. He chose Phoenix. "It's hard to say. In my mind, the NBA is the premier league," he said. That September the Suns played an exhibition against the Carolina Cougars in Cameron, and Melchionni, back in his old building in a new uniform beside Connie Hawkins and Charlie Scott, scored 14 points. "I really didn't want to play here now in front of my old fans," he admitted. "There's enough pressure just playing with the pros. But once I got in I felt okay." Coach John MacLeod said he would "definitely figure in the season ahead," and he did: 69 games and 7.2 points as a rookie, 68 games and 8.5 points in 1974-75, 137 NBA games in all.

He played four games for the Hazleton Bullets of the Eastern Basketball Association in 1975-76 and a season in Italy with Udinese in 1976-77. Then he stopped. "I had taken basketball as far as I was going to take it," he said later, and "a legal career seemed like a very good way to go." He had been admitted to Duke Law School as a senior and had deferred. He went back to Durham, finished his J.D. in 1981, and was admitted to the Pennsylvania bar that November and to New Jersey's two years later.

He settled in Lancaster, Pennsylvania, and practiced with Stevens & Lee, working mainly in employment and labor law. He and his wife, Karen, raised three children there. Their son Lee played four seasons at Duke for Mike Krzyzewski, from 2002 to 2006, and their daughter Monica went to Duke as well.

Where Is He Now

For Melchionni, Duke did not end with the degrees. He chaired the regional Alumni Admissions Advisory Committee and interviewed applicants, keeping track of the students he talked to, "a group that numbers in the hundreds." He joined the Duke Alumni Association board in 1994, chaired its awards, clubs and programming committees, and ran his class's 15th, 20th and 25th reunions. In 2001-02 he was president of the Duke Alumni Association, and in July 2001 he joined the university's Board of Trustees. "I'm very grateful that I had the chance to obtain two degrees from Duke, to play with some success in its basketball program," he said. "I've wanted to stay involved with Duke, and in that process to give something back to Duke." He came back to play, too, in the alumni games of 1980 and 1987, and he was on the 1990 alumni roster with Bucky Waters himself.

He is now retired from the practice of law and is about 75. In Lancaster he was a Rotarian and a volunteer youth basketball coach and organizer, which is to say he spent the years after basketball teaching the game he had once described as controlled, perpetual motion.

As a senior, thinking about the pros, he said, "I've always tried to perfect myself in as many facets of life as possible." Then he went and did it: the NBA, Italy, law school, a law practice, a son at Duke, a seat on the board of trustees. It is a long way from Melchionni Day, and it is the same idea. If a player stops moving, he might as well be a chair.

If you played with Gary Melchionni at Bishop Eustace, at Duke or in Phoenix, we would like to hear from you.

Career Highs

77 games · 2 starts · 7 20-point games · 1 30-point game · 1 double-double

Milestones

1972-73 Game Log

26 games · 15.8 ppg · 3.7 rpg · 3.1 apg · team stats

1972-73 game-by-game statistics
DateOpponentResultMINPTSREBASTSTLBLKTOFG3PTFT
Dec 2vsWilliam & MaryW 98-74251463———5-80-04-6
Dec 8atSanta ClaraW 69-65—132————5-140-03-3
Dec 9atSan FranciscoL 68-72—92————4-120-01-1
Dec 12vsEast CarolinaW 108-74291543———6-140-03-4
Dec 15vsNorth CarolinaL 86-91372053———8-200-04-4
Dec 16vsWake ForestW 80-67342031———8-170-04-5
Dec 27atUNLVL 83-89382034———9-160-02-3
Dec 28vsPurdueL 77-82361373———5-130-03-5
Dec 30vsHarvardW 102-76361460———6-140-02-2
Jan 3atVirginiaL 74-80431013———4-180-02-2
Jan 6atWake ForestL 80-83—430———2-80-00-0
Jan 10atNC StateL 87-94372141———9-140-03-3
Jan 13vsClemsonW 75-73391043———3-100-04-4
Jan 17atDavidsonW 78-75391831———5-110-08-8
Jan 20atNorth CarolinaL 71-8239716———2-120-03-4
Jan 24atRichmondW 70-66361631———8-140-00-2
Jan 27atGeorgia TechL 86-88311633———6-110-04-5
Feb 3vsMarylandW 85-81393912———17-250-05-6
Feb 7vsWake ForestW 84-71372235———7-150-08-8
Feb 13vsVirginiaGSW 90-663316712——45-80-06-9
Feb 17vsNotre DameGSW 86-74391985———6-160-07-10
Feb 21vsNC StateL 50-74351343———6-130-01-2
Feb 24atMarylandL 68-96401723———7-130-03-3
Feb 28atClemsonL 50-75391032———5-140-00-0
Mar 3vsNorth CarolinaL 70-72392266———10-200-02-2
Mar 8vsVirginiaL 55-59401422———7-160-00-0
Per game36.515.83.73.1——4.045.1%—81.2%

1971-72 Game Log

22 games · 11.8 ppg · 3.0 rpg · 2.6 apg · team stats

1971-72 game-by-game statistics
DateOpponentResultMINPTSREBASTSTLBLKTOFG3PTFT
Dec 1vsRichmondW 54-42401482———5-140-04-4
Dec 4vsVirginiaL 77-86241025———4-70-02-3
Dec 23vsDaytonW 68-663010———0-10-00-0
Dec 27vsSaint Peter'sL 74-77—1404———5-110-04-5
Dec 28vsSyracuseL 72-74—931———4-100-01-2
Jan 5vsVirginia TechW 83-73—169————7-160-02-2
Jan 12atNC StateL 58-8532935———3-70-03-3
Jan 15vsClemsonW 71-69401214———2-60-08-8
Jan 19vsCanisiusW 86-58321332———4-90-05-6
Jan 22vsNorth CarolinaW 76-74401225———3-70-06-9
Jan 26vsWake ForestW 77-6637524———2-50-01-1
Feb 5atMarylandL 58-77351210———4-80-04-4
Feb 9atWake ForestL 57-62—1730———7-130-03-4
Feb 12vsWilliam & MaryW 87-69241353———6-140-01-1
Feb 16atDavidsonL 72-74391230———4-90-04-4
Feb 19atVirginiaW 86-76391634———6-80-04-5
Feb 23vsNC StateW 74-73441144———5-100-01-2
Feb 26vsMarylandW 68-59391133———5-90-01-2
Mar 1atClemsonL 40-5937722———3-80-01-1
Mar 4atNorth CarolinaL 69-93—171————7-130-03-3
Mar 9vsNC StateW 73-60391653———7-130-02-4
Mar 10vsNorth CarolinaL 48-63391311———6-150-01-1
Per game34.311.83.02.6———46.5%—82.4%

1970-71 Game Log

29 games · 4.6 ppg · 1.6 rpg · 1.6 apg · team stats

1970-71 game-by-game statistics
DateOpponentResultMINPTSREBASTSTLBLKTOFG3PTFT
Dec 1vsPrincetonW 79-75291085———3-120-04-4
Dec 5atVirginiaL 70-75—227———1-60-00-0
Dec 7vsMichiganW 95-7418812———4-40-00-0
Dec 12atSouth CarolinaL 78-982000———0-00-00-0
Dec 15vsVirginia TechW 104-7513212———1-50-00-0
Dec 18vsWake ForestL 77-839212———1-10-00-0
Dec 19vsNorth CarolinaL 81-83—10————0-00-01-3
Dec 22atDaytonW 70-64—00————0-20-00-0
Dec 26vsSanta ClaraW 86-803000———0-10-00-0
Dec 29vsNorthwesternW 93-87—22————1-60-00-0
Dec 30vsPenn StateW 67-56—21————0-20-02-2
Jan 6atWake ForestW 68-67300————0-10-00-0
Jan 9atNorth CarolinaL 74-7913304———1-10-01-1
Jan 13vsNC StateL 89-938011———0-10-00-1
Jan 16atClemsonW 82-56—22————1-50-00-0
Feb 1vsSouth CarolinaW 82-7126811———0-30-08-8
Feb 10vsWake ForestW 83-788200———1-10-00-0
Feb 13atMarylandW 70-67—70————1-20-05-5
Feb 16vsDavidsonW 64-5518420———1-20-02-3
Feb 20vsVirginiaW 101-69161121———4-40-03-3
Feb 24atNC StateW 82-7823700———2-30-03-3
Feb 27vsSeton HallW 89-61—411———0-40-04-4
Mar 2vsClemsonW 70-60291132———4-70-03-3
Mar 6vsNorth CarolinaW 92-83341545———4-60-07-10
Mar 11vsNC StateL 61-6826461———2-80-00-0
Mar 20vsDaytonW 68-60—420———2-40-00-0
Mar 22vsTennesseeW 78-64—312———0-10-03-3
Mar 25vsNorth CarolinaL 67-73—1240———5-80-02-3
Mar 27vsSt. BonaventureL 88-92—620———2-60-02-2
Per game16.44.61.61.6———38.7%—86.2%

Sources

All quotes are sourced from published interviews and reporting.Read about our research methodology.

Support the Emily K Center

Founded by Coach K and his wife Mickie in honor of his mother, the Emily Krzyzewski Center provides educational support and life skills programming to students in Durham’s underserved communities.

Donate to Emily Krzyzewski Center