Road to Duke
On a Friday night in February 1972, after he had gone to Bucky Waters's house and told him he was quitting, Richie O'Connor went over to the Indoor Stadium and shot baskets. "I looked around and realized that I had played in other famous gymnasiums," he said a few days later, "but that Duke fans are without a doubt the most inspirational." He was averaging 15.4 points a game. He never played another game there.
He came from Union City, New Jersey, across the Hudson from Manhattan, and from St. Michael's High School, where he broke the school scoring records of Tom Heinsohn, the Celtics star who was by then their coach. O'Connor scored 2,025 points, the fifth-highest career total in New Jersey history to that point, and was a high school All-American. Waters, newly hired at Duke in the spring of 1969, won the recruiting battle for him. O'Connor remembered what sold him. "I expected to be told to tell everyone how great it is at Duke, but the coaches told us to tell it like it is and be completely honest about our feelings," he said as a freshman. "Their honest approach really affected me because I know how sickening and confusing dishonest recruiting can be."
At Duke
He was one of the "highly touted frosh five" of 1969-70, with Gary Melchionni, Alan Shaw, Jeff Dawson and Jim Fitzsimmons, and the team went 16-0, Duke's first unbeaten freshman team. O'Connor, a 6-5 swingman who could play forward or guard, averaged 20.7 points and 11.3 rebounds. He had 26 in the opener. He wanted to go to law school, carried a 2.7 his first semester, planned a summer trip to England, and worried, the paper reported, about whether he would be treated as a jock or as a person. "By my senior year," he said, "I hope that I will know at least half of the people on this campus."
Before his sophomore season he wrote that the team's talent should be "sufficient enough to secure an ACC championship for Duke," and he quoted advice from his brother, then an assistant coach at Dartmouth: "when the going gets tough, the tough get going." He started on a 20-10 team, averaged 12.7 points, and was named to the all-tournament team at the NIT, where Duke finished fourth. A Chronicle columnist that December thought he was "beginning to look a lot like Larry Miller." He had also, by then, watched Fitzsimmons and Don Blackman leave the program, and Dawson would follow in the fall. The next fall, when Waters had each class elect a representative to speak for it, the juniors chose O'Connor.
In 1971-72 he was the scorer. He made 16 of 21 free throws against Wake Forest in the Big Four Tournament and made the all-tournament team. On January 22, 1972, the night the building became Cameron Indoor Stadium, he scored 24 points in the 76-74 upset of third-ranked North Carolina, and he and Robby West kept Carolina at bay down the stretch. He scored 20 or more in five of seven games. By February he was among the ACC's top ten scorers at 16.6 points a game. Then he went into a slump, Duke lost two games on the road, and on Thursday, February 10, Waters moved him and Chris Redding to the second unit. Redding won his job back in practice. On Friday night O'Connor went to Waters's home and said he was quitting.
Waters issued a statement the next day that mentioned O'Connor's "mild scoring slump" and the need "to challenge our starters," and a Chronicle columnist wrote that it "strongly intimated" he was a quitter. O'Connor flew home to Union City to talk to his parents. His mother told a reporter she wanted "to hear his side." Then he came back and spent more than an hour with the Chronicle. "In a way, I was offended by the press release," he said, "and I think that it's inconceivable that I would quit Duke University because I wasn't starting one game. As far as this decision is concerned, it has been the culmination of a long period of thought instead of a rash decision." He would not say much more. "It basically comes down to personal conflict between myself and Coach Waters concerning style of basketball and my contribution to the team," he said. "I won't say anything derogatory about Coach Waters. I left because I have certain beliefs about the game of basketball, what it should mean to me, and I can't put up this facade that I'm very happy and extremely dedicated to something that I'm questioning right now." When he told Waters he was leaving, he said, the coach "treated me like a man" and respected his decision.
He was the sixth scholarship player to leave Waters's program in three years. A student group that wanted Waters fired started handing out leaflets again, and when a Raleigh television station reported that the team had voted to keep O'Connor out, eight of the nine remaining players said the report was false. He still finished the season as Duke's leading scorer at 15.4 points a game; for the rest of the year the box scores listed his points under "Others."
After Duke
He finished the spring semester at Duke and transferred to Fairfield University in Connecticut, closer to home, with a running team, Madison Square Garden on the schedule and a coach, Fred Barakat, he liked. His new teammates elected him a captain before he had played a game for them. After sitting out 1972-73 under the transfer rule, he averaged 17.3 points, the team high, for a 17-9 team in 1973-74. In January 1974 the Chronicle's Andy Burness, who had covered his departure, went to Fairfield and found him "contented, free of the burdens that beset his basketball experiences at Duke." "I'm enjoying hoop as much as I did in high school," O'Connor said. "We don't play an ACC-calibre schedule, and academically, Duke and Fairfield are as different as day and night, but I still prefer it here to Duke." Barakat was candid: "He'll have to work on his quickness if he has any pro aspirations." O'Connor was realistic, too. "I have to hope that the pro team that drafts me is looking for the talents that I can offer. If things don't work out, there's always European ball."
The Kansas City-Omaha Kings drafted him in the eighth round of the 1974 NBA draft. He never played in the NBA.
He did not lose touch with Duke. In the mid-1970s a high school guard from Jersey City, the next town over, named Jim Spanarkel, who had played against him in summer games, asked him about the place. "Richie was a good example of a person who would give me the straight-forward thing about Duke," Spanarkel said in 1979. "He never said one bad thing about Duke University or his experience, besides the hassle he had with the coaches. He laid everything on the table and told me everything about Duke that was good." Spanarkel added: "Sometimes I wonder if he regretted leaving, but that was his decision." By 1979 Spanarkel was the second-leading scorer in Duke history. The same interview mentions an article O'Connor wrote about Mike Gminski for Sport magazine, which ran a Gminski feature in March 1979.
Where Is He Now
We have not been able to find where Richie O'Connor went after that. He would be about 75. We searched his name with Union City, St. Michael's, Fairfield and Sport magazine, as Richie, Rich and Richard, and found no obituary we could tie to him and no later profile.
The story people tell about him is the leaving: the sixth player out the door, the slump, the press release, the television report. The record holds something else. He was the freshman who chose Duke because the coaches told him to be honest, and then he was honest about leaving, in the only terms he would use: a style of basketball he believed in, and a refusal to pretend. A few years later he was telling a kid from the next town over the truth about Duke, and the kid came.
On his last night as a Blue Devil, he went to the empty building and shot. If you played with Richie O'Connor at St. Michael's, at Duke or at Fairfield, or know where his life went after basketball, we would like to hear from you.