Road to Duke
The first time Bucky Waters coached Alan Shaw, Shaw was a high school freshman at a summer basketball camp, already tall and not yet ready. "Coach Waters worked with me at a basketball camp my freshman year in high school and he taught me many good moves, but I could not absorb them then," he said a few years later. By then Waters was Duke's head coach, Shaw was his center, and the lessons were sinking in.
In between, Shaw rewrote the record book at Millville High School in South Jersey. As a senior in 1968-69 he averaged 29 points, 21 rebounds and eight assists a game for a team that went 26-1. He was all-state as a junior and a senior and made three high school All-American teams, Scholastic Coach's among them. The Chronicle reported that about 250 schools contacted him. When Duke landed him in the spring of 1969, along with Gary Melchionni from Pennsauken and Jim Fitzsimmons from Connecticut, it described Millville's 6-11, 215-pound center as "big in stature as well as in ability."
Waters explained why so much of that class came from New Jersey: the state had no big public university that kept its players home, and he had played his own high school ball there. Shaw arrived in the fall of 1969 with Melchionni, Richie O'Connor, Jeff Dawson and Fitzsimmons, the "highly touted frosh five," and freshman coach Jack Schalow put him at center.
At Duke
The 1969-70 freshmen went 16-0. Shaw scored 29 in the opener against Virginia Tech, had 16 points and 16 rebounds against Carolina's freshmen, and set the Duke freshman records for the season with 34 points and 26 rebounds against Old Dominion. He also learned a new position. "Last year I played outside a lot and came to Duke with no real inside moves," he said. "Rarely did I face anyone my size and so this season I have had to adjust to the rough action under the basket." The adjustment was not always peaceful: against Davidson's freshmen he and John Pecorak traded punches and were both ejected. He averaged 14.6 points and nearly 15 rebounds, carried a 2.9 grade average, and was studying sociology and psychology. He found the classes "easier than I had anticipated," he said, "but there is still a good deal of work involved."
As a sophomore in 1970-71 he shared the post behind Randy Denton and captain Larry Saunders on a 20-10 team that finished fourth in the NIT. He averaged 6.4 points, and for a while he led the nation in free throw shooting at 44 of 48, which amused everyone who remembered that he had been the worst foul shooter of the four freshman stars.
Then Denton graduated, and in 1971-72 Shaw became what the Chronicle called Duke's "40 minuteman," averaging 39 minutes a game. He was a tri-captain. On January 22, 1972, the night the building became Cameron Indoor Stadium, he took 12 rebounds against Carolina's front line and did most of the work in holding Bob McAdoo to five points, fifteen below his average, in a 76-74 upset of the third-ranked Tar Heels. "We hardly played any man-to-man underneath," he said afterward, giving the credit to the crowd instead. "The fans were just tremendous. They were great . . . you cannot overestimate their effect on the ball game." He thought the team had changed. "This year we are more of a team than last year," he said. "Basketball is a lot more fun for me, because of this attitude."
A month later, in a 74-73 overtime win over NC State, he scored 15 points in the second half against 7-4 Tommy Burleson and finished with 19 points and 17 rebounds. "Tom Burleson was just clogging up the middle, so I tried to force him to come outside, opening up the middle," he said. "I was intimidated somewhat in the first half, but I decided to take it to him the second half." He was named ACC Player of the Week, finished second in the league in rebounding at 11.8 a game behind Burleson, led Duke in field goal percentage, and made the second-team All-ACC. At the team banquet he was named Duke's most valuable player. That winter he also spoke for the team when Richie O'Connor quit and a television report claimed the players had voted to shut him out. "People on the team agree that Richie had his own personal reasons for leaving," Shaw said. "I don't know how anyone on the team can know these reasons better than Richie."
His senior year started with a penalty that had nothing to do with him. In August 1972 the NCAA barred Duke from the 1973 postseason because a booster had taken a recruit, reported to be David Thompson, to the ACC Tournament and bought him a sport coat and trousers, and the Chronicle's photo caption noted that Shaw, "a second team all-ACC performer a year ago, will forfeit possible post-season exposure." He was a co-captain again and the league's writers again put him on their preseason second team, but the offense ran through Chris Redding, which a Chronicle columnist blamed for what happened next: Shaw slumped. Three times he was held to a single point. By February he was coming off the bench, and the Chronicle wrote that he had "revitalized his talents of a year ago." He finished at 8.8 points and 7.6 rebounds on a 12-14 team. After the ACC Tournament loss to Virginia, Waters thanked his two seniors, Melchionni and Shaw, for three years of "outstanding service."
After Duke
Waters had said that February that both of them wanted to play professionally. "I would like to think that both could make a pro team if they play up to their potential and I hope they will have the opportunity," he said. In May 1973 the Virginia Squires took Shaw in the fifth round of the ABA's supplemental draft. He never played in the ABA. By the fall of 1974 the Chronicle was reporting that "former Duke standout Alan Shaw" was playing professionally in Italy.
He stayed in Europe for five years. We know that, and most of what followed, from Shaw himself: a short note on his Millville High School class of 1969 alumni page, under his name, which reads, "After college, five years of basketball in Europe, then many years of teaching in NJ/CA... For the last eight years I've been developing tests at Educational Testing Service in Princeton." The page lists his occupation as assessment specialist. It is a self-written profile, undated and unverified, and we have not found his Italian clubs or the schools where he taught. But a Millville graduate of 1969 who played five years of professional basketball in Europe after college is a description that fits one man.
Where Is He Now
It is a good place for a Duke center to have ended up. Shaw came to Durham as a high school All-American who had played facing the basket, was rebuilt into a post player who could hold McAdoo to five points, and spent his freshman year telling the Chronicle that the work was easier than he expected but still work. Then he played in Europe, taught school on both coasts, and went to work at the company that writes the tests other students sit for.
He would be about 75. We do not know where he lives now, or whether he is still in Princeton.
In February 1973, with his own job in trouble, Bucky Waters was asked what the future held for Shaw and Melchionni. He talked about the pros first, and then about the other possibility. "If pro ball is not for them, I still will feel good about their futures because of the type of men they are, and because a degree from Duke should make them competitive for the rest of their lives." It was the coach who had first shown Shaw a post move at a summer camp, when he was too young to use it, and it turned out to be the right guess about both halves of his life.
If you played with Alan Shaw at Millville, at Duke or in Italy, taught with him in New Jersey or California, or worked with him at ETS, we would like to hear from you.