Road to Duke
On a Tuesday morning in September 1973, fifteen Duke basketball players were called to the locker room at eight o'clock and sat waiting, half asleep, for another meeting to start. One of them leaned his head against a metal locker and closed his eyes. Three days later the Chronicle printed what he had been thinking, under a headline that read "A player's perspective." It began plainly: "My name is Jeff Burdette and I am a senior basketball player."
What followed is the most vivid account we have of the end of the Bucky Waters era, written by a player who, by his own account, had helped bring it about. To understand the letter you have to understand the player, and the player had arrived three years earlier as the kind of guard coaches build around without ever putting his name in a headline.
He came from Berkeley Heights, New Jersey, and Governor Livingston Regional High School, which the town then shared with neighboring Mountainside. He was 5-foot-11 and about 165 pounds, a wide receiver in the fall and a point guard in the winter. A teammate who played two years behind him there, writing on the Duke Basketball Report forum in 2019, remembered him as "very much a 'pass first' point guard" who probably left as the school's career scoring leader anyway, and described the whole Governor Livingston press offense in one line: "inbound the ball to Jeff and everyone head up court." Before games he warmed up by throwing full-court passes to his big men, a habit the teammate thought came from football, where quarterbacks and receivers play catch on the sideline. The same teammate recalled that they all understood he was going to William & Mary until Bucky Waters visited late in his senior season, with, as he remembered it, one scholarship left.
Two people who knew him say his family moved to the Los Angeles area after he finished high school. As a freshman the Chronicle called him "a native of Berkeley Hgts., N.J."; by his junior year he was "a junior from Buena Park, Cal.," and Buena Park is how Duke's records have listed him ever since. In 2019 the Duke historian Jim Sumner, having named Burdette Duke's first ACC-era player from California, set the record straight after hearing from Burdette's old teammate: he no longer had any confidence that Burdette had played high school basketball in California. He had played it in New Jersey, and Duke saw what he could do as soon as he arrived.
At Duke
Freshmen could not play varsity basketball in 1970-71, and Burdette's class was a big one: Dave Elmer, Chris Redding, Ron Righter and Sam May up front, all 6-5 or taller. Looking back in January on how the season had looked at the start, the Chronicle wrote that "the big men all lacked bulk and the backcourt was questionable with Jeff Burdette the only scholarship guard." Jack Schalow's freshmen went 13-3 anyway, and the Chronicle kept saying the same thing about the guard. Against East Carolina's freshmen he scored 11 and drew eight charging fouls. Against Laurinburg Institute he was "the team's fine point man," with seven assists. Against Carolina's freshmen, in a 68-65 comeback win, he "played another fine floor game." When Elmer scored 40 and held NC State's 7-4 Tommy Burleson to 10 in an 80-72 upset of the unbeaten Wolfpack freshmen, Burdette "ran the ball club with his usual finesse, setting up most of the Duke scoring." Schalow's highest praise came in passing. Previewing Carolina, he described their guard Ray Hite as a "Burdette type player," one who "plays tough, hard defense and is a play-maker."
That fall Waters, after what the Chronicle called "some problems last season, both on and off the court," had each class elect a representative to speak for it. The sophomores chose Burdette. He started the 1971-72 opener against Richmond, and a week later, with Gary Melchionni hurt, he ran the team through a 50-49 overtime loss to Chuck Daly's Penn. Waters said he "played an outstanding game." He had brought the high school warmup with him. A Duke student of the early 1970s still remembered, decades later, watching Burdette and Alan Shaw throw full-length passes to each other before every game: "craziest warm up I've ever seen."
He could not shoot, and everyone knew it. By mid-January he had lost his starting job to Robby West, and when two Chronicle sports editors built an "efficiency" rating for the team, Burdette, shooting .391 from the field and .333 from the line, "finishes in the red." They added that he was "one of the team's top defensive players, and defensive ability is not included in this rating." In February, when Richie O'Connor quit the team and a Raleigh television station reported that the players had voted to keep him out, Burdette was one of eight who said the report was wrong. "We care about Richie as a person," he said, "and we wanted to keep the door open, in case Richie decided he had made a mistake in leaving." He finished the season at 1.7 points a game in 24 games.
As a junior he started again, beside Melchionni in the exhibition against Chile and the opener against William & Mary, and in mid-December he and Melchionni were still the guards getting the most minutes. By the end he had played in 20 games and scored 16 points for a team that went 12-14, Duke's first losing season in 34 years. In the spring of 1973 the student members of the Athletic Council gave the players a questionnaire about the program, and the results went to the council on April 7. By Burdette's own account, the players went further than a questionnaire. That spring, he wrote later, he had led "a group of players who felt like I did about Bucky as a coach. We wanted him out."
On Tuesday, September 11, 1973, Waters walked into the locker room and told them he was resigning. Burdette's letter describes the coach he had spent hours arguing with "across his desk": the eyes that never looked away, the chin that jutted out "as if he was challenging the world to a fistfight." Waters, he wrote, had tried to understand what the players felt, "but he could not come out of his own mind and try to put himself in our place. He couldn't understand. He tried, but he couldn't." Perhaps, he wrote, Waters believed the pressure could never bend him "as it had bent all the players, how it had bent me till I was a walking shell." And then that morning: "His head was tilted downward and his eyes stared into the sweat-stained carpet."
He did not pretend to be sorry. "I am glad that he is not my coach anymore. Anything I said that would sound like I wanted him to stay would be a lie." But he could not shake the sadness, and he explained it with a memory of a boxing match his father took him to as a child, the two fighters who seemed to hate each other falling into each other's arms at the final bell, and his father telling him he wouldn't understand. "Well father, I think I understand now." The letter ends: "It's sad to think that though so many of us have succeeded in disposing of a coach, we had to break a man to do it. I hope he realizes that he wins. Now that the final game is over, he wins."
The day the news broke, the veterans the Chronicle reached had all spoken of Waters with respect; Bob Fleischer called him "a very morally upright man whom nobody holds anything against personally." Burdette's letter was the other half of that story. A month later, in an editorial about what belonged in the Chanticleer yearbook, the Chronicle said that "Jeff Burdette's open letter deserves to be published in a permanent medium."
After Duke
His senior season, under Neill McGeachy, was the quietest of the three. He played in 13 games and made one of 15 shots. In February the Chronicle listed him among the guards who "have all exhibited the potential" to back up Billerman and freshman Edgar Burch but had not yet shown "the consistency required of an ACC guard." McGeachy saw something else. At midseason, asked about the leadership on a young team, he named his captain and then added: "Our two seniors, Chris Redding and Jeff Burdette have also contributed strongly in that respect." The team went 10-16 and finished last in the ACC, and Burdette, with the rest of the class of 1974, was gone before Bill Foster arrived.
His Duke line reads 57 games and 59 points. It leaves out the part the Chronicle saw every week as a freshman and the part nobody else could have written as a senior.
Where Is He Now
We do not know where Jeff Burdette went after Duke. He would be about 74. We searched his name with Berkeley Heights, Governor Livingston, Buena Park, Durham and Duke, as Jeff and as Jeffrey; looked for a LinkedIn page and an obituary; and read every Chronicle story we could find that mentions him, from 1970 to 1974. After the spring of 1974 his name does not appear there again.
What we have is one morning. A senior who had led the players against their coach sat in the locker room and watched the coach admit he was finished, and instead of celebrating he went home and wrote about his father and a boxing match. He was the point guard who never could make his shot but could throw a pass the length of the floor and see all of it, and in that letter he saw the whole floor at once: the coach, the players, the crowd that wanted him to smile, and himself. "Well father, I think I understand now."
If you played with Jeff Burdette at Governor Livingston or at Duke, or know where his life went after 1974, we would like to hear from you.