Road to Duke
In the fall of 1972 the NCAA let freshmen play varsity basketball, and the five scholarship freshmen Bucky Waters brought to Duke that September were the first class at the school who could. The Chronicle introduced them one at a time. "Rounding out the five is Dave O'Connell, from Cincinnati, Ohio. O'Connell, a versatile 6-2, will see action as both a forward and a guard." The freshmen were asked about the seven players who had quit the program in less than three years, and the paper decided the best answer came from O'Connell: "If they want to leave that's their problem, not mine."
He came from a basketball family. His uncle Tim O'Connell was a two-sport star at Xavier in the 1960s, drafted by the Indiana Pacers in basketball and the Yankees in baseball, and is in the school's athletics hall of fame; his uncle Mike played at Notre Dame from 1967 to 1970. Dave was the one who jumped. Before he had played a varsity game the Chronicle was calling him "a freshman guard with superb jumping ability," and in Duke's exhibition against the Chilean national team on November 29, 1972, a 118-54 rout in front of about 500 people, he scored 18 points, one fewer than Chris Redding's game high, on what the paper called "flying lay-ups" and "leaping lay-ups" that "excited the miniscule crowd." Three nights later, in the opener against William and Mary, "freshman sensation Dave O'Connell spun and leaped his way to nine points." He and Willie Hodge were the two freshmen who made the varsity to stay; Paul Fox, Terry Chili and Bob Cook went to the jayvees. By January a columnist was writing that "a driving guard with O'Connell's leaping ability adds yet another dimension in a balanced offense."
That was the high point of the record, and he was 18. He played 23 games as a freshman, averaged 2.7 points, and the shooting percentage, 31 percent from the floor, told the truth: he could get to the rim and he could not yet shoot. He was a player built entirely on his legs, on a team going 12-14, with a coach about to quit. Then the legs went.
At Duke
Waters resigned in September 1973, effective October 1, and the Chronicle went looking for players to react. Hodge was gracious. "Dave O'Connell, another freshman player last year, echoed Hodge. 'I'm very disappointed to see him go, but I can understand the circumstances,' stated O'Connell. 'I definitely have no gripes against him, and regard him highly both as a man and as a coach.'" The paper ran his picture over the story with a caption that could have stood for the whole program: "Dave O'Connell, one of Bucky Waters' top recruits a year ago, must now wonder who his new coach will be."
It was Neill McGeachy, for one year, and O'Connell spent most of it hurt. He missed the November exhibition with a leg injury, missed "all but nine days of pre-season practice" with a knee, and his first real game came on December 10, 1973, when he came off the bench against Appalachian State and scored ten, "the most encouraging note of the evening for the Devils," the paper wrote; "the sparkling leaper's drives to the bucket inspired Duke to a second half rally that buried the visitors." McGeachy counted him among the bench "capable of helping us at key times" in January. He finished the season with 27 points in 22 games. The next fall, Bill Foster's first day of practice, it happened again. "I guess I should have guessed something like this was going to happen on the first day of practice," Foster said the following March. "Armstrong was diagnosed as having a slight case of mono. Crow was in the hospital, O'Connell got hurt and was out for the season, I had to call off practice the next day. That's never happened to me before." He had surgery on his knees, both of them, and did not play a minute of his junior year.
His son Alex, forty-some years later, told a recruiting reporter the family version: his father was "a hyper-athletic guard" who "ended up hurting his knees and his career sort of ended. It was actually a motorcycle accident. He was riding and hurt both of his knees. And medical procedures weren't as good as they are today." The Chronicle never printed how it happened, only that it did, and what it cost. When the paper previewed his senior year in December 1975 it described "swingman Dave O'Connell, who has never really had the chance to prove himself because of surgical knees that caused him to miss his entire junior season."
The senior year was his chance, and for a month in the middle of it he took it. At Clemson on January 14, 1976, he scored nine points with four rebounds. Three nights later, against seventh-ranked North Carolina in Cameron, he scored ten, "all in the last ten minutes," including the drive with 8:18 left that put Duke up 73-65 with the building coming apart, and then, with the game tied in the last two minutes, the play the Chronicle could not let go of: "O'Connell drove to the hoop and Mitch Kupchak came out to meet him. The two collided as Kupchak stuffed the shot and no foul was called. Instead, referee Lou Moser called for a jump ball." Carolina won 89-87. "One of the few bright spots in the back-breaking defeats to Clemson and Carolina was the play of senior Dave O'Connell," the paper wrote. "The 6'4" swingman, who has come back from knee surgery this season, has gone to the hoop very well in the last two contests. If he can continue to be effective he could give the team a real boost." Two nights after that, against 20th-ranked Virginia Tech in Greensboro, he shot 4 of 6 in eleven first-half minutes with a steal and "tenacious defense," one of three reserves, with Fox and Chili, whose play "proved a difference," and Foster, asked what his bench was made of, deadpanned, "Wood." He got the last basket at N.C. State on January 24, an uncontested layup at the buzzer in a 106-101 loss, the night Kenny Carr scored 44. A student columnist, reviewing the Wake Forest win, gave him the sentence the whole career had been waiting for: "Dave O'Connell, who has determination as well as guts and desire (for those of you uninitiated to his knee problems), played many minutes and scored only when he had the opportunity, nearly without fail." By February he was the "top reserve" and "number one frontcourt reserve" on the team. He was shooting 54 percent.
On February 14, 1976, in Philadelphia, before the St. Joseph's game, he twisted the surgical knee in the pregame warm-up. "How serious the injury was has not been determined," the Chronicle wrote on Monday, "but any problem with a surgical knee is potentially disastrous." It was. He missed N.C. State, he missed the Maryland upset of February 21 that his classmates would talk about for fifty years, and on February 25, Senior Night, when the five seniors were honored before the Clemson game, the paper noted that "the 6'4" Cincinnati senior will not play his final game in the Indoor Stadium because of the knee injury he aggravated ten days ago in Philadelphia." He watched in street clothes with Spanarkel. He did not play again. Nineteen games, 95 points, 5.0 a game, 64 games and 183 points for a career. That spring he was given the Ted Mann Jr. Award, for the reserve who had contributed most to team morale, the same award Chili had won the two years before.
After Duke
He left Duke with a bachelor's degree in marketing, two surgically repaired knees and, his LinkedIn page still notes under "Activities and societies," a line for Varsity Basketball between City Leadership Group and Habitat for Humanity, and in September 1976 he went to work for Ryder System in Miami. He stayed eighteen years. He was a district manager for the truck-leasing company, running the sales and service functions for its Southeast division, Florida, Georgia, Alabama and South Carolina, and later moved into the Miami corporate office as director of training and development, the man who taught the salesmen how to sell. In September 1994 he moved to Equifax, the Atlanta credit bureau, as an account executive in what became its Workforce Solutions business, the division that sells employment and income verification to big employers, and that job moved him around the country for twenty-three years: Baltimore, where his sons Shawn and Alex were born in 1995 and 1999; Los Angeles; and finally Atlanta. "It was just jobs," Alex said in 2016, when a reporter asked why the family had moved so much. "He was moving all over the country." After a few months with Corporate Cost Control in 2018 he finished at Experian, Equifax's rival, as a senior account executive managing thirty of the company's largest enterprise clients, from May 2018 until July 2025, when he retired at about 71 after forty-nine years of selling to companies: trucks, then data. None of it ever mentioned Duke basketball. Only the one line on the resume did.
What he did with his evenings is a matter of public record, because all three boys play. He raised them on the game and on his own old Duke film. "My dad has taught me all about the game," Alex said, "so I know a lot about the game." Shawn, 6-foot-8, played at Georgia Southern and finished as a graduate transfer at UNC Wilmington in 2019. Alex, 6-foot-6, was the first commitment of Duke's 2017 class, a four-star shooting guard from Milton High School who "had been visiting Duke ever since I was little," and who became, in the words of every roster bio the school printed, a second-generation Blue Devil: "Father played basketball at Duke from 1973-76." Brady, the youngest, played his senior year of high school at Ravenscroft in Raleigh for a head coach named Kevin Billerman, his father's teammate and classmate from the Waters, McGeachy and Foster years, and then went to Old Dominion.
Asked in 2016 about his father, Alex said the thing that every description of Dave O'Connell since 1972 has said in one way or another. "He wasn't a shooter as much as me, but he was the same athleticism as me."
Where Is He Now
On a Saturday in January 1976, Dave O'Connell drove on Mitch Kupchak with the game tied and Cameron on its feet and did not get the call. On a Saturday in February 2019, with Zion Williamson hurt and Duke at Syracuse, his son made his first start of the season and scored a career-high 20, in a Duke uniform, on two good knees. Dave O'Connell watched that one, as he and Crystal watched everything, dividing the week between three sons' schedules. "There are three, four, five, six games a week that they have to figure out where to go to," Shawn said that winter. "We just divide and conquer," his mother said.
He is about 72, retired since the summer of 2025, and lives in the north Atlanta suburbs, in Milton, where the family settled in the early 2000s. He has never given an interview about Duke that we can find, and the only words of his on the record are a freshman's and a sophomore's, both of them, you will notice, about loyalty. Of the five freshmen who arrived together in 1972, he was the one whose game depended most on his body and the one whose body gave out first, and he is also the one who put it back into the program in the most literal way possible: a son who wore the uniform for three years, played 101 games, and got the ovations in Cameron that the knees never let the father have. He never did get to play his Senior Night. His kid got three years in the building.
If you played with Dave O'Connell at Duke or in Cincinnati, or worked with him at Ryder, Equifax or Experian, we would like to hear from you, and we would very much like to hear from him.