Road to Duke
In February 1972, when a Raleigh television station reported that Duke's players had voted to shut Richie O'Connor out of the program, the Chronicle reached one of the team's three captains at home on a Friday evening. He was a senior who had scored 26 points in three varsity seasons, and he explained more fully than anyone what the team had and had not done. "The team does not want judicial powers and does not have the right to judge its peers on personal problems," Pat Doughty said. "The meeting was definitely not a trial."
He came to Duke from Herrin, a coal town in southern Illinois, where he was a co-captain of the football and basketball teams in 1968, first-team captain of the All-South team, the Elks' most valuable player, and a nine-time letterman in football, basketball and track. He was also nominated to the U.S. Military Academy. Instead he took a basketball scholarship from Vic Bubas, in the last class Bubas signed before he retired. When he got to Durham the Chronicle described him as "a fine shooter and playmaker," 5-foot-10, one of only four scholarship players on the 1968-69 freshman team. Duke's later rosters list his hometown as Tempe, Arizona: his parents left Herrin for Scottsdale in 1968, the year he finished high school, according to his mother's obituary.
At Duke
The freshmen were short and played fast. Hubie Brown, in his first year at Duke, coached them, and Doughty ran the fast break. In December 1968 he and Robby West carried the freshmen to a 59-48 upset of NC State's tall, highly rated freshmen; West scored 16 and Doughty 14, two quick jumpers of his breaking a State run. When he missed a game in January, sick in bed, the Chronicle noted that his "excellent ball handling abilities would have been a big help." When he fouled out against Davidson, his "defensive abilities and playmaking were sorely missed." He averaged about eight points a game. "Both Doughty and West (the two scholarship guards) have all the determination and the right attitude," Brown said. "It's just going to take a lot of work."
Then the coaches changed. Bubas retired, Bucky Waters arrived from West Virginia in the spring of 1969, and the next fall brought the best freshman class in years. Doughty played in two varsity games as a sophomore, eight as a junior and 13 as a senior. Before his junior season, when the Chronicle asked the players to write about their goals, he wrote that "to be a Duke basketball player is a privilege," and that "just to be associated with the university itself is a privilege." He was an engineering major.
As a senior in 1971-72 he was a tri-captain with Gary Melchionni and Alan Shaw, and the Chronicle kept listing him among the guards who might see action. A columnist in January wrote that Doughty and the other deep reserves were not "jovial about their occasional minute of action." He made the most of the ones he got. Against William & Mary he threw a series of fast-break passes for easy layups, and in the 86-76 upset at sixth-ranked Virginia he "played exceptionally well in the second half." In the O'Connor affair he was the senior who spoke at the greatest length. "We didn't even talk about whether or not Richie was justified in leaving the team," he said. "After the meeting the team considered the matter dropped. All we want to do is play basketball the best we can. We support the Duke program, and I think that is evidenced by our actions on the basketball court."
Before his last ACC Tournament he said: "This Tournament will be a new experience like my first one was, because it will be my last and if we lose a game that will also be my last game." Duke beat NC State and lost to North Carolina. At the banquet that spring his teammates gave him the award for the reserve contributing the most to team morale.
After Duke
He graduated in 1972 with his engineering degree, and by then home was Arizona. His mother Norma's obituary says the family was "originally from Herrin, Illinois and moved to Scottsdale in 1968," and lists Pat among her sons.
What we can document after that belongs to a Pat Doughty in the Phoenix area, and we think it is the same man, for reasons we explain below. Mirachem Corporation was founded in 1978 to make water-based industrial cleaning products, the kind that replace the solvents factories and machine shops had used for decades to strip grease from metal parts. A Pat Doughty was the company's contact in Tempe in March 1990, when a federal evaluation of cleanup technologies for the Exxon Valdez oil spill listed Mirachem's water-soluble cleaner and degreaser among the products tested. By 1997 he was co-owner and chief operating officer. That November, EHS Today interviewed him for a story on substituting safer materials in industry. He advised companies to start small, said that when Mirachem had a new product for a customer its first call went to the industrial hygiene or safety group rather than the purchasing department, and put the burden on his own side of the business: "It's the chemical manufacturer's job to make sure there is no smoking gun." He was optimistic about where it was headed. "Companies are just beginning to see what's possible," he said.
Mirachem's chemistry went into Heritage-Crystal Clean's parts-cleaning service from 2004, and in its 2013 fiscal year Heritage-Crystal Clean bought substantially all of Mirachem's operating assets. Mirachem, LLC, headquartered in Phoenix, now describes itself as a Heritage-Crystal Clean company.
The identification is ours, so here is what it rests on. The name is the same, and Pat is the shortened form the Duke player used. The Duke player's family moved to the Phoenix area in 1968, and his later Duke rosters list Tempe, where Mirachem was based. He studied engineering, and Mirachem was a chemical manufacturer. Public records also list a Patrick J. Doughty of the right age at addresses in Tempe and other Phoenix suburbs, with a Norma Doughty among his relatives. None of the Mirachem sources mentions Duke or basketball, though, and none of the Duke sources mentions Mirachem. If we have the wrong man, we will correct it.
In 2016 Herrin High School put him in its athletic hall of fame, with a list of honors that ends: "Attended Duke University on Basketball Scholarship."
Where Is He Now
He would be about 76. What survives of his Duke career is mostly what he said, not what he scored: 26 points in 23 varsity games, and then, in the worst month of a bad era, a captain who refused to let a television report turn a team meeting into a verdict. "The team does not want judicial powers," he said, "and does not have the right to judge its peers on personal problems."
If the Mirachem executive is our Pat Doughty, the rest of his working life ran on the same instinct. He spent it making products that took the harshest chemicals out of factories, and he told an industry magazine that the burden of proof sat with the people who made the chemicals, not the people who used them. It is the reserve's view of a team: someone has to look after the people the stars never think about.
He came as a three-sport captain who had been nominated to West Point, and he left with an engineering degree and an award for keeping up everyone else's spirits. Somebody on the bench has to do that. In 1972 it was the captain.
If you played with Pat Doughty at Herrin or at Duke, or worked with him at Mirachem, we would like to hear from you, and especially to confirm that the Duke guard and the Mirachem executive are the same man.